ICU Disparnumerophobia and Triskaidekaphobia: The 'Irrational Care Unit'?

07/01/2019
by   Ari Ercole, et al.
0

Whilst evidence-based medicine is the cornerstone of modern practice, it is likely that clinicians are influenced by cultural biases. This work set out to look for evidence of number preference in invasive mechanical ventilatory therapy as a concrete example of subconscious treatment bias. A retrospective observational intensive care electronic medical record database search and analysis was carried out in adult general, specialist neurosciences and paediatric intensive care units within a tertiary referral hospital. All admitted, invasively mechanically ventilated patients between October 2014 and August 2015 were included. Set positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP), respiratory rate (RR) and inspiratory pressure (Pinsp) settings were extracted. Statistical analysis using conventional testing and a novel Monte Carlo method were used to look for evidence of two culturally prevalent superstitions: Odd/even preference and aversion to the number 13. Patients spent significantly longer with odd choices for PEEP (OR=0.16, p<2×10^-16), RR (OR=0.31, p<2×10^-16) and Pinsp (OR=0.48, p=2.9×10^-7). An aversion to the number 13 was detected for choices of RR (p=0.00024) and Pinsp (p=3.9×10^-5). However a PEEP of 13 was more prevalent than expected by chance (p=0.00028). These findings suggest superstitious preferences in intensive care therapy do exist and practitioners should be alert to guard against other, less obvious but perhaps more clinically significant decision-making biases. The methodology described may be useful for detecting statistically significant number preferences in other domains.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
03/23/2017

The Dependence of Machine Learning on Electronic Medical Record Quality

There is growing interest in applying machine learning methods to Electr...
research
04/20/2017

A Reinforcement Learning Approach to Weaning of Mechanical Ventilation in Intensive Care Units

The management of invasive mechanical ventilation, and the regulation of...
research
06/29/2020

Predicting Length of Stay in the Intensive Care Unit with Temporal Pointwise Convolutional Networks

The pressure of ever-increasing patient demand and budget restrictions m...
research
07/18/2020

Temporal Pointwise Convolutional Networks for Length of Stay Prediction in the Intensive Care Unit

The pressure of ever-increasing patient demand and budget restrictions m...
research
11/17/2017

Improving Palliative Care with Deep Learning

Improving the quality of end-of-life care for hospitalized patients is a...
research
01/16/2021

Predicting Hyperkalemia in the ICU and Evaluation of Generalizability and Interpretability

Hyperkalemia is a potentially life-threatening condition that can lead t...
research
07/16/2017

An Ensemble Boosting Model for Predicting Transfer to the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit

Our work focuses on the problem of predicting the transfer of pediatric ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset