I Beg to Differ: A study of constructive disagreement in online conversations

01/26/2021
by   Christine de Kock, et al.
8

Disagreements are pervasive in human communication. In this paper we investigate what makes disagreement constructive. To this end, we construct WikiDisputes, a corpus of 7 425 Wikipedia Talk page conversations that contain content disputes, and define the task of predicting whether disagreements will be escalated to mediation by a moderator. We evaluate feature-based models with linguistic markers from previous work, and demonstrate that their performance is improved by using features that capture changes in linguistic markers throughout the conversations, as opposed to averaged values. We develop a variety of neural models and show that taking into account the structure of the conversation improves predictive accuracy, exceeding that of feature-based models. We assess our best neural model in terms of both predictive accuracy and uncertainty by evaluating its behaviour when it is only exposed to the beginning of the conversation, finding that model accuracy improves and uncertainty reduces as models are exposed to more information.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 3

page 8

research
07/06/2023

Exploring Linguistic Style Matching in Online Communities: The Role of Social Context and Conversation Dynamics

Linguistic style matching (LSM) in conversations can be reflective of se...
research
05/25/2021

The Structure of Toxic Conversations on Twitter

Social media platforms promise to enable rich and vibrant conversations ...
research
08/30/2021

Linguistic Characterization of Divisive Topics Online: Case Studies on Contentiousness in Abortion, Climate Change, and Gun Control

As public discourse continues to move and grow online, conversations abo...
research
12/22/2017

Find the Conversation Killers: a Predictive Study of Thread-ending Posts

How to improve the quality of conversations in online communities has at...
research
02/16/2021

Conversations Gone Alright: Quantifying and Predicting Prosocial Outcomes in Online Conversations

Online conversations can go in many directions: some turn out poorly due...
research
03/13/2020

WAC: A Corpus of Wikipedia Conversations for Online Abuse Detection

With the spread of online social networks, it is more and more difficult...
research
05/14/2018

Conversations Gone Awry: Detecting Early Signs of Conversational Failure

One of the main challenges online social systems face is the prevalence ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset