DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

How Reliable are Test Numbers for Revealing the COVID-19 Ground Truth and Applying Interventions?

by   Aditya Gopalan, et al.
indian institute of science

The number of confirmed cases of COVID-19 is often used as a proxy for the actual number of ground truth COVID-19 infected cases in both public discourse and policy making. However, the number of confirmed cases depends on the testing policy, and it is important to understand how the number of positive cases obtained using different testing policies reveals the unknown ground truth. We develop an agent-based simulation framework in Python that can simulate various testing policies as well as interventions such as lockdown based on them. The interaction between the agents can take into account various communities and mobility patterns. A distinguishing feature of our framework is the presence of another `flu'-like illness with symptoms similar to COVID-19, that allows us to model the noise in selecting the pool of patients to be tested. We instantiate our model for the city of Bengaluru in India, using census data to distribute agents geographically, and traffic flow mobility data to model long-distance interactions and mixing. We use the simulation framework to compare the performance of three testing policies: Random Symptomatic Testing (RST), Contact Tracing (CT), and a new Location Based Testing policy (LBT). We observe that if a sufficient fraction of symptomatic patients come out for testing, then RST can capture the ground truth quite closely even with very few daily tests. However, CT consistently captures more positive cases. Interestingly, our new LBT, which is operationally less intensive than CT, gives performance that is comparable with CT. In another direction, we compare the efficacy of these three testing policies in enabling lockdown, and observe that CT flattens the ground truth curve maximally, followed closely by LBT, and significantly better than RST.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


From policy to prediction: Forecasting COVID-19 dynamics under imperfect vaccination

Understanding the joint impact of vaccination and non-pharmaceutical int...

Automated Quantification of CT Patterns Associated with COVID-19 from Chest CT

Purpose: To present a method that automatically segments and quantifies ...

Group Testing under Superspreading Dynamics

Testing is recommended for all close contacts of confirmed COVID-19 pati...

Estimating Active Cases of COVID-19

Having accurate and timely data on confirmed active COVID-19 cases is ch...

Network-Side Digital Contact Tracing on a Large University Campus

We describe a study conducted at a large public university campus in the...