DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

How reliable and useful is Cabell's Blacklist ? A data-driven analysis

by   Christophe Dony, et al.

In scholarly publishing, blacklists aim to register fraudulent or deceptive journals and publishers, also known as "predatory", to minimise the spread of unreliable research and the growing of fake publishing outlets. However, blacklisting remains a very controversial activity for several reasons: there is no consensus regarding the criteria used to determine fraudulent journals, the criteria used may not always be transparent or relevant, and blacklists are rarely updated regularly. Cabell's paywalled blacklist service attempts to overcome some of these issues in reviewing fraudulent journals on the basis of transparent criteria and in providing allegedly up-to-date information at the journal entry level. We tested Cabell's blacklist to analyse whether or not it could be adopted as a reliable tool by stakeholders in scholarly communication, including our own academic library. To do so, we used a copy of Walt Crawford's Gray Open Access dataset (2012-2016) to assess the coverage of Cabell's blacklist and get insights on their methodology. Out of the 10,123 journals that we tested, 4,681 are included in Cabell's blacklist. Out of this number of journals included in the blacklist, 3,229 are empty journals, i.e. journals in which no single article has ever been published. Other collected data points to questionable weighing and reviewing methods and shows a lack of rigour in how Cabell applies its own procedures: some journals are blacklisted on the basis of 1 to 3 criteria, identical criteria are recorded multiple times in individual journal entries, discrepancies exist between reviewing dates and the criteria version used and recorded by Cabell, reviewing dates are missing, and we observed two journals blacklisted twice with a different number of violations. Based on these observations, we conclude with recommendations and suggestions that could help improve Cabell's blacklist service.


page 1

page 8

page 11

page 27

page 29

page 30

page 31

page 34


Sustainability of ICT hardware procurement in Switzerland – A status-quo analysis of the public procurement sector

Sustainable procurement requires organizations to align their purchasing...

On basis set optimisation in quantum chemistry

In this article, we propose general criteria to construct optimal atomic...

Comparing Process Calculi Using Encodings

Encodings or the proof of their absence are the main way to compare proc...

Continual Learning for Unsupervised Anomaly Detection in Continuous Auditing of Financial Accounting Data

International audit standards require the direct assessment of a financi...

Eficiency of REST and gRPC realizing communication tasks in microservice-based ecosystems

The aim of this contribution is to analyse practical aspects of the use ...