How Relevant Are Chess Composition Conventions?

by   Azlan Iqbal, et al.

Composition conventions are guidelines used by human composers in composing chess problems. They are particularly significant in composition tournaments. Examples include, not having any check in the first move of the solution and not dressing up the board with unnecessary pieces. Conventions are often associated or even directly conflated with the overall aesthetics or beauty of a composition. Using an existing experimentally-validated computational aesthetics model for three-move mate problems, we analyzed sets of computer-generated compositions adhering to at least 2, 3 and 4 comparable conventions to test if simply conforming to more conventions had a positive effect on their aesthetics, as is generally believed by human composers. We found slight but statistically significant evidence that it does, but only to a point. We also analyzed human judge scores of 145 three-move mate problems composed by humans to see if they had any positive correlation with the computational aesthetic scores of those problems. We found that they did not. These seemingly conflicting findings suggest two main things. First, the right amount of adherence to composition conventions in a composition has a positive effect on its perceived aesthetics. Second, human judges either do not look at the same conventions related to aesthetics in the model used or emphasize others that have less to do with beauty as perceived by the majority of players, even though they may mistakenly consider their judgements beautiful in the traditional, non-esoteric sense. Human judges may also be relying significantly on personal tastes as we found no correlation between their individual scores either.



There are no comments yet.


page 8


The Digital Synaptic Neural Substrate: A New Approach to Computational Creativity

We introduce a new artificial intelligence (AI) approach called, the 'Di...

Who/What is My Teammate? Team Composition Considerations in Human-AI Teaming

There are many unknowns regarding the characteristics and dynamics of hu...

The Sum Composition Problem

In this paper, we study the "sum composition problem" between two lists ...

Covariance within Random Integer Compositions

Fix a positive integer N. Select an additive composition ξ of N uniforml...

Composition of Credal Sets via Polyhedral Geometry

Recently introduced composition operator for credal sets is an analogy o...

A Computer Composes A Fabled Problem: Four Knights vs. Queen

We explain how the prototype automatic chess problem composer, Chestheti...

A Perceptual Model of Musical Mix Clarity using Decomposition and Masking Thresholds

Objective measurement of perceptually motivated music attributes has app...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.