How and Why do Researchers Reference Data? A Study of Rhetorical Features and Functions of Data References in Academic Articles

02/16/2023
by   Sara Lafia, et al.
0

Data reuse is a common practice in the social sciences. While published data play an essential role in the production of social science research, they are not consistently cited, which makes it difficult to assess their full scholarly impact and give credit to the original data producers. Furthermore, it can be challenging to understand researchers' motivations for referencing data. Like references to academic literature, data references perform various rhetorical functions, such as paying homage, signaling disagreement, or drawing comparisons. This paper studies how and why researchers reference social science data in their academic writing. We develop a typology to model relationships between the entities that anchor data references, along with their features (access, actions, locations, styles, types) and functions (critique, describe, illustrate, interact, legitimize). We illustrate the use of the typology by coding multidisciplinary research articles (n=30) referencing social science data archived at the Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR). We show how our typology captures researchers' interactions with data and purposes for referencing data. Our typology provides a systematic way to document and analyze researchers' narratives about data use, extending our ability to give credit to data that support research.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 25

research
09/11/2020

Citing and referencing habits in Medicine and Social Sciences journals in 2019

This article explores citing and referencing systems in Social Sciences ...
research
05/23/2022

A Natural Language Processing Pipeline for Detecting Informal Data References in Academic Literature

Discovering authoritative links between publications and the datasets th...
research
10/11/2017

The number of linked references of publications in Microsoft Academic in comparison with the Web of Science

In the context of a comprehensive Microsoft Academic (MA) study, we expl...
research
06/17/2021

Data sharing of computer scientists: an analysis of current research information system data

Without sufficient information about researchers data sharing, there is ...
research
07/07/2022

Will open science change authorship for good? Towards a quantitative analysis

Authorship of scientific articles has profoundly changed from early scie...
research
09/29/2021

On the reliability of published findings using the regression discontinuity design in political science

The regression discontinuity (RD) design offers identification of causal...
research
04/22/2021

"I'm a Professor, which isn't usually a dangerous job": Internet-Facilitated Harassment and its Impact on Researchers

While the Internet has dramatically increased the exposure that research...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset