Hard Choices in Artificial Intelligence

by   Roel Dobbe, et al.

As AI systems are integrated into high stakes social domains, researchers now examine how to design and operate them in a safe and ethical manner. However, the criteria for identifying and diagnosing safety risks in complex social contexts remain unclear and contested. In this paper, we examine the vagueness in debates about the safety and ethical behavior of AI systems. We show how this vagueness cannot be resolved through mathematical formalism alone, instead requiring deliberation about the politics of development as well as the context of deployment. Drawing from a new sociotechnical lexicon, we redefine vagueness in terms of distinct design challenges at key stages in AI system development. The resulting framework of Hard Choices in Artificial Intelligence (HCAI) empowers developers by 1) identifying points of overlap between design decisions and major sociotechnical challenges; 2) motivating the creation of stakeholder feedback channels so that safety issues can be exhaustively addressed. As such, HCAI contributes to a timely debate about the status of AI development in democratic societies, arguing that deliberation should be the goal of AI Safety, not just the procedure by which it is ensured.



There are no comments yet.



Hard Choices in Artificial Intelligence: Addressing Normative Uncertainty through Sociotechnical Commitments

As AI systems become prevalent in high stakes domains such as surveillan...

AI Development for the Public Interest: From Abstraction Traps to Sociotechnical Risks

Despite interest in communicating ethical problems and social contexts w...

Hard Choices and Hard Limits for Artificial Intelligence

Artificial intelligence (AI) is supposed to help us make better choices....

System Safety and Artificial Intelligence

This chapter formulates seven lessons for preventing harm in artificial ...

Mediating Artificial Intelligence Developments through Negative and Positive Incentives

The field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is going through a period of g...

The Tragedy of the AI Commons

Policy and guideline proposals for ethical artificial-intelligence resea...

Modelling the Safety and Surveillance of the AI Race

Innovation, creativity, and competition are some of the fundamental unde...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.