From Philosophy to Interfaces: an Explanatory Method and a Tool Inspired by Achinstein's Theory of Explanation

09/09/2021
by   Francesco Sovrano, et al.
University of Bologna
0

We propose a new method for explanations in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and a tool to test its expressive power within a user interface. In order to bridge the gap between philosophy and human-computer interfaces, we show a new approach for the generation of interactive explanations based on a sophisticated pipeline of AI algorithms for structuring natural language documents into knowledge graphs, answering questions effectively and satisfactorily. Among the mainstream philosophical theories of explanation we identified one that in our view is more easily applicable as a practical model for user-centric tools: Achinstein's Theory of Explanation. With this work we aim to prove that the theory proposed by Achinstein can be actually adapted for being implemented into a concrete software application, as an interactive process answering questions. To this end we found a way to handle the generic (archetypal) questions that implicitly characterise an explanatory processes as preliminary overviews rather than as answers to explicit questions, as commonly understood. To show the expressive power of this approach we designed and implemented a pipeline of AI algorithms for the generation of interactive explanations under the form of overviews, focusing on this aspect of explanations rather than on existing interfaces and presentation logic layers for question answering. We tested our hypothesis on a well-known XAI-powered credit approval system by IBM, comparing CEM, a static explanatory tool for post-hoc explanations, with an extension we developed adding interactive explanations based on our model. The results of the user study, involving more than 100 participants, showed that our proposed solution produced a statistically relevant improvement on effectiveness (U=931.0, p=0.036) over the baseline, thus giving evidence in favour of our theory.

READ FULL TEXT
POST COMMENT

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Authors

page 12

10/02/2021

Generating User-Centred Explanations via Illocutionary Question Answering: From Philosophy to Interfaces

We propose a new method for generating explanations with Artificial Inte...
04/05/2019

Lucid Explanations Help: Using a Human-AI Image-Guessing Game to Evaluate Machine Explanation Helpfulness

While there have been many proposals on how to make AI algorithms more t...
12/16/2021

Explanation as Question Answering based on Design Knowledge

Explanation of an AI agent requires knowledge of its design and operatio...
09/09/2021

Modelling GDPR-Compliant Explanations for Trustworthy AI

Through the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the European Unio...
07/08/2020

Explaining Natural Language Query Results

Multiple lines of research have developed Natural Language (NL) interfac...
11/19/2020

Iterative Planning with Plan-Space Explanations: A Tool and User Study

In a variety of application settings, the user preference for a planning...
05/01/2020

The Grammar of Interactive Explanatory Model Analysis

When analysing a complex system, very often an answer for one question r...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.