Formalizing Falsification of Causal Structure Theories for Consciousness Across Computational Hierarchies

06/12/2020
by   Jake R. Hanson, et al.
0

There is currently a global, multimillion-dollar effort to experimentally confirm or falsify neuroscience's preeminent theory of consciousness: Integrated Information Theory (IIT). Yet, recent theoretical work suggests major epistemic concerns regarding the validity of IIT and all so-called "causal structure theories". In particular, causal structure theories are based on the assumption that consciousness supervenes on a particular causal structure, despite the fact that different causal structures can lead to the same input-output behavior and global functionality. This, in turn, leads to epistemic problems when it comes to the ability to falsify such a theory - if two systems are functionally identical, what remains to justify a difference in subjective experience? Here, we ground these abstract epistemic problems in a concrete example of functionally indistinguishable systems with different causal architectures. Our example comes in the form of an isomorphic feed-forward decomposition ("unfolding") of a simple electronic tollbooth, which we use to demonstrate a clear falsification of causal structure theories such as IIT. We conclude with a brief discussion regarding the level of formal description at which a candidate measure of consciousness must operate if it is to be considered scientific.

READ FULL TEXT
research
10/30/2020

Thinking About Causation: A Causal Language with Epistemic Operators

This paper proposes a formal framework for modeling the interaction of c...
research
08/03/2019

Integrated Information Theory and Isomorphic Feed-Forward Philosophical Zombies

Any theory amenable to scientific inquiry must have testable consequence...
research
03/01/2014

Tractable Epistemic Reasoning with Functional Fluents, Static Causal Laws and Postdiction

We present an epistemic action theory for tractable epistemic reasoning ...
research
06/10/2022

A Causal Research Pipeline and Tutorial for Psychologists and Social Scientists

Causality is a fundamental part of the scientific endeavour to understan...
research
09/18/2023

Causal Theories and Structural Data Representations for Improving Out-of-Distribution Classification

We consider how human-centered causal theories and tools from the dynami...
research
11/25/2019

Theory-based Causal Transfer: Integrating Instance-level Induction and Abstract-level Structure Learning

Learning transferable knowledge across similar but different settings is...
research
07/20/2023

Characterising Decision Theories with Mechanised Causal Graphs

How should my own decisions affect my beliefs about the outcomes I expec...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset