Evidential Confirmation as Transformed Probability

03/27/2013
by   Benjamin N. Grosof, et al.
0

A considerable body of work in AI has been concerned with aggregating measures of confirmatory and disconfirmatory evidence for a common set of propositions. Claiming classical probability to be inadequate or inappropriate, several researchers have gone so far as to invent new formalisms and methods. We show how to represent two major such alternative approaches to evidential confirmation not only in terms of transformed (Bayesian) probability, but also in terms of each other. This unifies two of the leading approaches to confirmation theory, by showing that a revised MYCIN Certainty Factor method [12] is equivalent to a special case of Dempster-Shafer theory. It yields a well-understood axiomatic basis, i.e. conditional independence, to interpret previous work on quantitative confirmation theory. It substantially resolves the "taxe-them-or-leave-them" problem of priors: MYCIN had to leave them out, while PROSPECTOR had to have them in. It recasts some of confirmation theory's advantages in terms of the psychological accessibility of probabilistic information in different (transformed) formats. Finally, it helps to unify the representation of uncertain reasoning (see also [11]).

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 3

page 6

page 7

research
12/04/2018

Statistics with improper posteriors

In 1933 Kolmogorov constructed a general theory that defines the modern ...
research
01/07/2014

Tractability through Exchangeability: A New Perspective on Efficient Probabilistic Inference

Exchangeability is a central notion in statistics and probability theory...
research
03/21/2023

Indeterminate Probability Neural Network

We propose a new general model called IPNN - Indeterminate Probability N...
research
10/24/2017

Improper posteriors are not improper

In 1933 Kolmogorov constructed a general theory that defines the modern ...
research
03/27/2013

Lp : A Logic for Statistical Information

This extended abstract presents a logic, called Lp, that is capable of r...
research
11/09/2018

Reasoning From Data in the Mathematical Theory of Evidence

Mathematical Theory of Evidence (MTE) is known as a foundation for reaso...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset