Evaluating the relative contribution of data sources in a Bayesian analysis with the application of estimating the size of hard to reach populations

by   Jacob Parsons, et al.

When using multiple data sources in an analysis, it is important to understand the influence of each data source on the analysis and the consistency of the data sources with each other and the model. We suggest the use of a retrospective value of information framework in order to address such concerns. Value of information methods can be computationally difficult. We illustrate the use of computational methods that allow these methods to be applied even in relatively complicated settings. In illustrating the proposed methods, we focus on an application in estimating the size of hard to reach populations. Specifically, we consider estimating the number of injection drug users in Ukraine by combining all available data sources spanning over half a decade and numerous sub-national areas in the Ukraine. This application is of interest to public health researchers as this hard to reach population that plays a large role in the spread of HIV. We apply a Bayesian hierarchical model and evaluate the contribution of each data source in terms of absolute influence, expected influence, and level of surprise. Finally we apply value of information methods to inform suggestions on future data collection.



There are no comments yet.


page 17


A Bayesian hierarchical modeling approach to combining multiple data sources: A case study in size estimation

To combat the HIV/AIDS pandemic effectively, certain key populations pla...

The Value of Information in Retrospect

In the course of any statistical analysis, it is necessary to consider i...

A Bayesian Evidence Synthesis Approach to Estimate Disease Prevalence in Hard-To-Reach Populations: Hepatitis C in New York City

Existing methods to estimate the prevalence of chronic hepatitis C (HCV)...

Fast approaches for Bayesian estimation of size of hard-to-reach populations using Network Scale-up

The Network scale-up method is commonly used to overcome difficulties in...

Construcción de un Mapa de Vulnerabilidad Sanitaria en Argentina a partir de datos públicos

This document is intended to present in detail the processing criteria a...

Contribution of Conceptual Modeling to Enhancing Historians' Intuition -Application to Prosopography

Historians, and in particular researchers in prosopography, focus a lot ...

Thirty Years of The Network Scale up Method

Estimating the size of hard-to-reach populations is an important problem...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.