Evaluating the Impact of State-Level Public Masking Mandates on New COVID-19 Cases and Deaths in the United States: A Demonstration of the Causal Roadmap

10/12/2021
by   Angus K. Wong, et al.
0

At a national-level, we sought to investigate the effect of public masking mandates on COVID-19 in Fall 2020. Specifically, we aimed to evaluate how the relative growth of COVID-19 cases and deaths would have differed if all states had issued a mandate to mask in public by September 1, 2020 versus if all states had delayed issuing such a mandate. To do so, we applied the Causal Roadmap, a formal framework for causal and statistical inference. The outcome was defined as the state-specific relative increase in cumulative cases and in cumulative deaths 21, 30, 45, 60-days after September 1. Despite the natural experiment in state-level masking policies, the causal effect of interest was not identifiable. Nonetheless, we specified the target statistical parameter as the adjusted rate ratio (aRR): the expected outcome with early implementation divided by the expected outcome with delayed implementation, after adjusting for state-level confounders. To minimize strong estimation assumptions, primary analyses used targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) with Super Learner. After 60-days and at a national-level, early implementation was associated 9 reduction in new COVID-19 cases (aRR: 0.91; 95 reduction in new COVID-19 deaths (aRR: 0.84; 95 of identifiability prohibited causal interpretations, application of the Causal Roadmap facilitated estimation and inference of statistical associations, providing timely answers to pressing questions in the COVID-19 response.

READ FULL TEXT

page 23

page 24

page 29

page 30

page 31

page 32

page 33

page 34

research
04/13/2020

The effect of stay-at-home orders on COVID-19 infections in the United States

In March and April 2020, public health authorities in the United States ...
research
03/13/2023

Application of targeted maximum likelihood estimation in public health and epidemiological studies: a systematic review

The Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimation (TMLE) statistical data analy...
research
05/29/2021

Assessing the Causal Impact of COVID-19 Related Policies on Outbreak Dynamics: A Case Study in the US

To mitigate the spread of COVID-19 pandemic, decision-makers and public ...
research
08/07/2020

Estimating undocumented Covid-19 infections in Cuba by means of a hybrid mechanistic-statistical approach

We adapt the hybrid mechanistic-statistical approach of Ref. [1] to esti...
research
03/24/2020

Mechanistic-statistical SIR modelling for early estimation of the actual number of cases and mortality rate from COVID-19

The first cases of COVID-19 in France were detected on January 24, 2020....
research
02/15/2023

Cross-Validated Decision Trees with Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimation for Nonparametric Causal Mixtures Analysis

Exposure to mixtures of chemicals, such as drugs, pollutants, and nutrie...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset