Dispersion vs Disparity: Hiding Variability Can Encourage Stereotyping When Visualizing Social Outcomes

08/08/2022
by   Eli Holder, et al.
0

Visualization research often focuses on perceptual accuracy or helping readers interpret key messages. However, we know very little about how chart designs might influence readers' perceptions of the people behind the data. Specifically, could designs interact with readers' social cognitive biases in ways that perpetuate harmful stereotypes? For example, when analyzing social inequality, bar charts are a popular choice to present outcome disparities between race, gender, or other groups. But bar charts may encourage deficit thinking, the perception that outcome disparities are caused by groups' personal strengths or deficiencies, rather than external factors. These faulty personal attributions can then reinforce stereotypes about the groups being visualized. We conducted four experiments examining design choices that influence attribution biases (and therefore deficit thinking). Crowdworkers viewed visualizations depicting social outcomes that either mask variability in data, such as bar charts or dot plots, or emphasize variability in data, such as jitter plots or prediction intervals. They reported their agreement with both personal and external explanations for the visualized disparities. Overall, when participants saw visualizations that hide within-group variability, they agreed more with personal explanations. When they saw visualizations that emphasize within-group variability, they agreed less with personal explanations. These results demonstrate that data visualizations about social inequity can be misinterpreted in harmful ways and lead to stereotyping. Design choices can influence these biases: Hiding variability tends to increase stereotyping while emphasizing variability reduces it.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
09/01/2023

Polarizing Political Polls: How Visualization Design Choices Can Shape Public Opinion and Increase Political Polarization

While we typically focus on data visualization as a tool for facilitatin...
research
03/15/2021

The Public Life of Data: Investigating Reactions to Visualizations on Reddit

This research investigates how people engage with data visualizations wh...
research
03/23/2023

Don't Peek at My Chart: Privacy-preserving Visualization for Mobile Devices

Data visualizations have been widely used on mobile devices like smartph...
research
10/25/2020

Let's Gamble: How a Poor Visualization Can Elicit Risky Behavior

Data visualizations are standard tools for assessing and communicating r...
research
09/15/2021

Data Hunches: Incorporating Personal Knowledge into Visualizations

The trouble with data is that often it provides only an imperfect repres...
research
05/24/2022

Justifying Social-Choice Mechanism Outcome for Improving Participant Satisfaction

In many social-choice mechanisms the resulting choice is not the most pr...
research
04/20/2018

Personal vs. Know-How Contacts: Which Matter More in Wiki Elections?

The use of social media affects the real world as well. This study relie...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset