Determining Possible and Necessary Winners Given Partial Orders

01/16/2014
by   Lirong Xia, et al.
0

Usually a voting rule requires agents to give their preferences as linear orders. However, in some cases it is impractical for an agent to give a linear order over all the alternatives. It has been suggested to let agents submit partial orders instead. Then, given a voting rule, a profile of partial orders, and an alternative (candidate) c, two important questions arise: first, is it still possible for c to win, and second, is c guaranteed to win? These are the possible winner and necessary winner problems, respectively. Each of these two problems is further divided into two sub-problems: determining whether c is a unique winner (that is, c is the only winner), or determining whether c is a co-winner (that is, c is in the set of winners). We consider the setting where the number of alternatives is unbounded and the votes are unweighted. We completely characterize the complexity of possible/necessary winner problems for the following common voting rules: a class of positional scoring rules (including Borda), Copeland, maximin, Bucklin, ranked pairs, voting trees, and plurality with runoff.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

02/21/2020

The Complexity of Determining the Necessary and Possible Top-k Winners in Partial Voting Profiles

When voter preferences are known in an incomplete (partial) manner, winn...
11/10/2017

Manipulative Elicitation -- A New Attack on Elections with Incomplete Preferences

Lu and Boutilier proposed a novel approach based on "minimax regret" to ...
12/14/2020

Trustworthy Preference Completion in Social Choice

As from time to time it is impractical to ask agents to provide linear o...
05/18/2020

Computing the Extremal Possible Ranks with Incomplete Preferences

In an election via a positional scoring rule, each candidate receives fr...
12/02/2011

Label Ranking with Abstention: Predicting Partial Orders by Thresholding Probability Distributions (Extended Abstract)

We consider an extension of the setting of label ranking, in which the l...
07/11/2018

Sequential Voting with Confirmation Network

We discuss voting scenarios in which the set of voters (agents) and the ...
05/11/2022

Who won? Winner Determination and Robustness in Liquid Democracy

Liquid democracy is a decision-making paradigm in which each agent can e...