DeSMOG: Detecting Stance in Media On Global Warming

10/28/2020
by   Yiwei Luo, et al.
0

Citing opinions is a powerful yet understudied strategy in argumentation. For example, an environmental activist might say, "Leading scientists agree that global warming is a serious concern," framing a clause which affirms their own stance ("that global warming is serious") as an opinion endorsed ("[scientists] agree") by a reputable source ("leading"). In contrast, a global warming denier might frame the same clause as the opinion of an untrustworthy source with a predicate connoting doubt: "Mistaken scientists claim [...]." Our work studies opinion-framing in the global warming (GW) debate, an increasingly partisan issue that has received little attention in NLP. We introduce DeSMOG, a dataset of stance-labeled GW sentences, and train a BERT classifier to study novel aspects of argumentation in how different sides of a debate represent their own and each other's opinions. From 56K news articles, we find that similar linguistic devices for self-affirming and opponent-doubting discourse are used across GW-accepting and skeptic media, though GW-skeptical media shows more opponent-doubt. We also find that authors often characterize sources as hypocritical, by ascribing opinions expressing the author's own view to source entities known to publicly endorse the opposing view. We release our stance dataset, model, and lexicons of framing devices for future work on opinion-framing and the automatic detection of GW stance.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
08/27/2019

Ideologically Motivated Biases in a Multiple Issues Opinion Model

It has been observed people tend to have opinions that are far more inte...
research
06/07/2023

Examining Bias in Opinion Summarisation Through the Perspective of Opinion Diversity

Opinion summarisation is a task that aims to condense the information pr...
research
03/28/2023

Language Models Trained on Media Diets Can Predict Public Opinion

Public opinion reflects and shapes societal behavior, but the traditiona...
research
08/23/2021

VerbCL: A Dataset of Verbatim Quotes for Highlight Extraction in Case Law

Citing legal opinions is a key part of legal argumentation, an expert ta...
research
07/09/2020

CompRes: A Dataset for Narrative Structure in News

This paper addresses the task of automatically detecting narrative struc...
research
12/03/2019

Facilitating on-line opinion dynamics by mining expressions of causation. The case of climate change debates on The Guardian

News website comment sections are spaces where potentially conflicting o...
research
04/19/2021

"Don't quote me on that": Finding Mixtures of Sources in News Articles

Journalists publish statements provided by people, or sources to context...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset