Counterfactual thinking in cooperation dynamics

by   Luís Moniz Pereira, et al.

Counterfactual Thinking is a human cognitive ability studied in a wide variety of domains. It captures the process of reasoning about a past event that did not occur, namely what would have happened had this event occurred, or, otherwise, to reason about an event that did occur but what would ensue had it not. Given the wide cognitive empowerment of counterfactual reasoning in the human individual, the question arises of how the presence of individuals with this capability may improve cooperation in populations of self-regarding individuals. Here we propose a mathematical model, grounded on Evolutionary Game Theory, to examine the population dynamics emerging from the interplay between counterfactual thinking and social learning (i.e., individuals that learn from the actions and success of others) whenever the individuals in the population face a collective dilemma. Our results suggest that counterfactual reasoning fosters coordination in collective action problems occurring in large populations, and has a limited impact on cooperation dilemmas in which coordination is not required. Moreover, we show that a small prevalence of individuals resorting to counterfactual thinking is enough to nudge an entire population towards highly cooperative standards.



There are no comments yet.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Learning enables adaptation in cooperation for multi-player stochastic games

Interactions among individuals in natural populations often occur in a d...

Evolutionary dynamics of cooperation in neutral populations

Cooperation is a difficult proposition in the face of Darwinian selectio...

Evolution of Cooperation in the Presence of Higher-Order Interactions: from Networks to Hypergraphs

Many real systems are strongly characterized by collective cooperative p...

Improved cooperation by balancing exploration and exploitation in intertemporal social dilemma tasks

When an individual's behavior has rational characteristics, this may lea...

Self-regulation promotes cooperation in social networks

Cooperative behavior in real social dilemmas is often perceived as a phe...

Latent Event-Predictive Encodings through Counterfactual Regularization

A critical challenge for any intelligent system is to infer structure fr...

Leaving bads provides better outcome than approaching goods in a social dilemma

Individual migration has been regarded as an important factor for the ev...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.