Comparing baseball players across eras via the novel Full House Model

07/22/2022
by   Shen Yan, et al.
0

We motivate a new methodological framework for era-adjusting baseball statistics. Our methodology is a crystallization of the conceptual ideas put forward by Stephen Jay Gould. We name this methodology the Full House Model in his honor. The Full House Model works by balancing the achievements of Major League Baseball (MLB) players within a given season and the size of the MLB eligible population. We demonstrate the utility of our Full House Model in an application of comparing baseball players' performance statistics across eras. Our results reveal a radical reranking of baseball's greatest players that is consistent with what one would expect under a sensible uniform talent generation assumption. Most importantly, we find that the greatest African American and Latino players now sit atop the greatest all-time lists of historical baseball players while conventional wisdom ranks such players lower. Our conclusions largely refute a consensus of baseball greatness that is reinforced by nostalgic bias, recorded statistics, and statistical methodologies which we argue are not suited to the task of comparing players across eras.

READ FULL TEXT

page 24

page 25

research
10/18/2018

Challenging nostalgia and performance metrics in baseball

In this manuscript, we show that the great baseball players that started...
research
03/14/2018

Removing Skill Bias from Gaming Statistics

"The chance to win given a certain move" is an easily obtainable quantit...
research
04/16/2021

An interactive dashboard for searching and comparing soccer performance scores

The performance of soccer players is one of most discussed aspects by ma...
research
09/13/2022

Prediction of the outcome of a Twenty-20 Cricket Match

Twenty20 cricket, sometimes written Twenty-20, and often abbreviated to ...
research
03/24/2016

Evaluating the Performance of Offensive Linemen in the NFL

How does one objectively measure the performance of an individual offens...
research
09/08/2020

The curse of rationality in sequential scheduling games

Despite the emphases on computability issues in research of algorithmic ...
research
10/17/2022

Visual Debates

The natural way of obtaining different perspectives on any given topic i...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset