Cognitive Model Priors for Predicting Human Decisions

05/22/2019
by   David D. Bourgin, et al.
10

Human decision-making underlies all economic behavior. For the past four decades, human decision-making under uncertainty has continued to be explained by theoretical models based on prospect theory, a framework that was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences. However, theoretical models of this kind have developed slowly, and robust, high-precision predictive models of human decisions remain a challenge. While machine learning is a natural candidate for solving these problems, it is currently unclear to what extent it can improve predictions obtained by current theories. We argue that this is mainly due to data scarcity, since noisy human behavior requires massive sample sizes to be accurately captured by off-the-shelf machine learning methods. To solve this problem, what is needed are machine learning models with appropriate inductive biases for capturing human behavior, and larger datasets. We offer two contributions towards this end: first, we construct "cognitive model priors" by pretraining neural networks with synthetic data generated by cognitive models (i.e., theoretical models developed by cognitive psychologists). We find that fine-tuning these networks on small datasets of real human decisions results in unprecedented state-of-the-art improvements on two benchmark datasets. Second, we present the first large-scale dataset for human decision-making, containing over 240,000 human judgments across over 13,000 decision problems. This dataset reveals the circumstances where cognitive model priors are useful, and provides a new standard for benchmarking prediction of human decisions under uncertainty.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
08/14/2018

Reconciling Irrational Human Behavior with AI based Decision Making: A Quantum Probabilistic Approach

There are many examples of human decision making which cannot be modeled...
research
05/13/2022

Modeling Human Behavior Part II – Cognitive approaches and Uncertainty

As we discussed in Part I of this topic, there is a clear desire to mode...
research
11/19/2021

SpeedyIBL: A Solution to the Curse of Exponential Growth in Instance-Based Learning Models of Decisions from Experience

Computational cognitive modeling is a useful methodology to explore and ...
research
12/09/2020

Model-agnostic Fits for Understanding Information Seeking Patterns in Humans

In decision making tasks under uncertainty, humans display characteristi...
research
06/21/2017

The Theory is Predictive, but is it Complete? An Application to Human Perception of Randomness

When we test a theory using data, it is common to focus on correctness: ...
research
05/24/2023

Using Models Based on Cognitive Theory to Predict Human Behavior in Traffic: A Case Study

The development of automated vehicles has the potential to revolutionize...
research
09/07/2018

Model of Cognitive Dynamics Predicts Performance on Standardized Tests

In the modern knowledge economy, success demands sustained focus and hig...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset