Can the Government Compel Decryption? Don't Trust – Verify

08/04/2022
by   Aloni Cohen, et al.
0

If a court knows that a respondent knows the password to a device, can the court compel the respondent to enter that password into the device? In this work, we propose a new approach to the foregone conclusion doctrine from Fisher v US that governs the answer to this question. The Holy Grail of this line of work would be a framework for reasoning about whether the testimony implicit in any action is already known to the government. In this paper we attempt something narrower. We introduce a framework for specifying actions for which all implicit testimony is, constructively, a foregone conclusion. Our approach is centered around placing the burden of proof on the government to demonstrate that it is not "rely[ing] on the truthtelling" of the respondent. Building on original legal analysis and using precise computer science formalisms, we propose demonstrability as a new central concept for describing compelled acts. We additionally provide a language for whether a compelled action meaningfully entails the respondent to perform in a manner that is 'as good as' the government's desired goal. Then, we apply our definitions to analyze the compellability of several cryptographic primitives including decryption, multifactor authentication, commitment schemes, and hash functions. In particular, our framework reaches a novel conclusion about compelled decryption in the setting that the encryption scheme is deniable: the government can compel but the respondent is free to use any password of her choice.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
11/29/2018

Correspondence Analysis of Government Expenditure Patterns

We analyze expenditure patterns of discretionary funds by Brazilian cong...
research
07/13/2020

An Enhanced Text Classification to Explore Health based Indian Government Policy Tweets

Government-sponsored policy-making and scheme generations is one of the ...
research
08/22/2021

M-Government, Wilaya and Women's Empowerment in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

With the loosening of the male guardianship system (Wilaya) in the Kingd...
research
02/11/2022

Tracking environmental policy changes in the Brazilian Federal Official Gazette

Even though most of its energy generation comes from renewable sources, ...
research
09/13/2022

LegalBench: Prototyping a Collaborative Benchmark for Legal Reasoning

Can foundation models be guided to execute tasks involving legal reasoni...
research
09/12/2022

What is a good doge? Analyzing the patrician social network of the Republic of Venice

The Venetian republic was one of the most successful trans-modern states...
research
08/22/2021

Empirical Study of Sustaining the Actualized Value Propositions of Implemented E-Government Projects in Sub-Saharan Africa

Governments in sub-Saharan Africa have implemented e-Government projects...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset