Biased Bytes: On the Validity of Estimating Food Consumption from Digital Traces

08/30/2022
by   Kristina Gligoric, et al.
0

Given that measuring food consumption at a population scale is a challenging task, researchers have begun to explore digital traces (e.g., from social media or from food-tracking applications) as potential proxies. However, it remains unclear to what extent digital traces reflect real food consumption. The present study aims to bridge this gap by quantifying the link between dietary behaviors as captured via social media (Twitter) v.s. a food-tracking application (MyFoodRepo). We focus on the case of Switzerland and contrast images of foods collected through the two platforms, by designing and deploying a novel crowdsourcing framework for estimating biases with respect to nutritional properties and appearance. We find that the food type distributions in social media v.s. food tracking diverge; e.g., bread is 2.5 times more frequent among consumed and tracked foods than on Twitter, whereas cake is 12 times more frequent on Twitter. Controlling for the different food type distributions, we contrast consumed and tracked foods of a given type with foods shared on Twitter. Across food types, food posted on Twitter is perceived as tastier, more caloric, less healthy, less likely to have been consumed at home, more complex, and larger-portioned, compared to consumed and tracked foods. The fact that there is a divergence between food consumption as measured via the two platforms implies that at least one of the two is not a faithful representation of the true food consumption in the general Swiss population. Thus, researchers should be attentive and aim to establish evidence of validity before using digital traces as a proxy for the true food consumption of a general population. We conclude by discussing the potential sources of these biases and their implications, outlining pitfalls and threats to validity, and proposing actionable ways for overcoming them.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 9

research
08/25/2018

You are what you eat: A social media study of food identity

Food preferences not only originate from a person's dietary habits, but ...
research
06/26/2019

Modeling Food Popularity Dependencies using Social Media data

The rise in popularity of major social media platforms have enabled peop...
research
08/31/2019

Scraping Social Media Photos Posted in Kenya and Elsewhere to Detect and Analyze Food Types

Monitoring population-level changes in diet could be useful for educatio...
research
05/12/2023

A Central Asian Food Dataset for Personalized Dietary Interventions, Extended Abstract

Nowadays, it is common for people to take photographs of every beverage,...
research
07/20/2023

Yelp Reviews and Food Types: A Comparative Analysis of Ratings, Sentiments, and Topics

This study examines the relationship between Yelp reviews and food types...
research
04/17/2019

Comparison of Self-monitoring Feedback Data from Electronic Food and Nutrition Tracking Tools

Changing dietary habits and keeping food diary encourages fewer calorie ...
research
08/02/2021

Bite-Weight Estimation Using Commercial Ear Buds

While automatic tracking and measuring of our physical activity is a wel...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset