Bento and the Art of Repeated Research
share
Bento provides a new approach to developing file systems, with safety and high-velocity development in mind. This is achieved by using Rust, a modern and memory-safe systems programming language, and by providing a framework to run a single file system implementation in kernel space with the VFS or in user space with FUSE. In this paper, the benchmarking experiments from the Bento paper are repeated. We fail to exactly reproduce the results of the Bento paper, but more or less find the same patterns albeit with more outlying results. Additionally we unsuccessfully run a standardized test suite, and expand the set of experiments with latency benchmarks and throughput benchmarks using a RAM block device. The latency benchmarks show that ext4 with journaling consistently outperforms Bento-fs and the RAM throughput benchmarks show no additional consistent performance pattern. During this experimentation, a set of 12 bugs was encountered and analyzed. We find that the ratio of memory related bugs is lower than other systems programming projects that use C as opposed to Rust, thus supporting the claims of the Bento framework.
READ FULL TEXT