Belief places and spaces: Mapping cognitive environments

07/08/2019
by   Philip Feldman, et al.
0

Beliefs are not facts, but they are factive -- feel like facts. This property is what can make misinformation dangerous. Being able to deliberately navigate through a landscape of often conflicting factive statements is difficult when there is no way to show the relationships between them without incorporating the information in linear, narrative forms. In this paper, we present a mechanism to produce maps of belief places, where populations agree on salient features of fictional environments, and belief spaces, where subgroups have related but distinct perspectives. Using a model developed using agent-based simulation, we show that by observing the repeated behaviors of human participants in the same social context, it is possible to build maps that show the shared narrative environment overlaid with traces that show unique, individual or subgroup perspectives. Our contribution is a proof-of-concept system, based on the affordances of fantasy tabletop role-playing games, which support multiple groups interacting with the same dungeon in a controlled, online environment. The techniques used in this process are mathematically straightforward, and should be generalizable to auto-generating larger-scale maps of belief spaces from other corpora, such as discussions on social media.

READ FULL TEXT

page 6

page 13

page 14

research
04/10/2019

Dungeons for Science: Mapping Belief Places and Spaces

Tabletop fantasy role-playing games (TFRPGs) have existed in offline and...
research
04/15/2018

Simon's Anthill: Mapping and Navigating Belief Spaces

In the parable of Simon's Ant, an ant follows a complex path along a bea...
research
03/23/2021

Is radicalization reinforced by social media censorship?

Radicalized beliefs, such as those tied to QAnon, Russiagate, and other ...
research
08/23/2022

New conceptions of truth foster misinformation in online public political discourse

The spread of online misinformation is increasingly perceived as a major...
research
10/04/2018

Graph-Theoretic Analysis of Belief System Dynamics under Logic Constraints

Opinion formation cannot be modeled solely as an ideological deduction f...
research
02/04/2020

From Topic Networks to Distributed Cognitive Maps: Zipfian Topic Universes in the Area of Volunteered Geographic Information

Are nearby places (e.g. cities) described by related words? In this arti...
research
05/12/2023

Detecting Coordinated Inauthentic Behavior in Likes on Social Media: Proof of Concept

Coordinated inauthentic behavior is used as a tool on social media to sh...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset