Automated Model Selection with Bayesian Quadrature

02/26/2019
by   Henry Chai, et al.
16

We present a novel technique for tailoring Bayesian quadrature (BQ) to model selection. The state-of-the-art for comparing the evidence of multiple models relies on Monte Carlo methods, which converge slowly and are unreliable for computationally expensive models. Previous research has shown that BQ offers sample efficiency superior to Monte Carlo in computing the evidence of an individual model. However, applying BQ directly to model comparison may waste computation producing an overly-accurate estimate for the evidence of a clearly poor model. We propose an automated and efficient algorithm for computing the most-relevant quantity for model selection: the posterior probability of a model. Our technique maximizes the mutual information between this quantity and observations of the models' likelihoods, yielding efficient acquisition of samples across disparate model spaces when likelihood observations are limited. Our method produces more-accurate model posterior estimates using fewer model likelihood evaluations than standard Bayesian quadrature and Monte Carlo estimators, as we demonstrate on synthetic and real-world examples.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
10/12/2018

Variational Bayesian Monte Carlo

Many probabilistic models of interest in scientific computing and machin...
research
10/28/2022

Bayesian Model Selection of Lithium-Ion Battery Models via Bayesian Quadrature

A wide variety of battery models are available, and it is not always obv...
research
01/19/2020

Distributionally Robust Bayesian Quadrature Optimization

Bayesian quadrature optimization (BQO) maximizes the expectation of an e...
research
11/15/2017

Bootstrapped synthetic likelihood

The development of approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) and synthetic ...
research
10/10/2019

Distributed Bayesian Computation for Model Choice

We propose a general method for distributed Bayesian model choice, where...
research
03/26/2022

Model Selection for Maternal Hypertensive Disorders with Symmetric Hierarchical Dirichlet Processes

Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy occur in about 10 around the world. ...
research
09/27/2022

Monte-Carlo Sampling Approach to Model Selection: A Primer

Any data modeling exercise has two main components: parameter estimation...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset