Authorized and Unauthorized Practices of Law: The Role of Autonomous Levels of AI Legal Reasoning

by   Lance Eliot, et al.

Advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) that are being applied to legal efforts have raised controversial questions about the existent restrictions imposed on the practice-of-law. Generally, the legal field has sought to define Authorized Practices of Law (APL) versus Unauthorized Practices of Law (UPL), though the boundaries are at times amorphous and some contend capricious and self-serving, rather than being devised holistically for the benefit of society all told. A missing ingredient in these arguments is the realization that impending legal profession disruptions due to AI can be more robustly discerned by examining the matter through the lens of a framework utilizing the autonomous levels of AI Legal Reasoning (AILR). This paper explores a newly derived instrumental grid depicting the key characteristics underlying APL and UPL as they apply to the AILR autonomous levels and offers key insights for the furtherance of these crucial practice-of-law debates.



There are no comments yet.


page 18

page 19

page 20

page 21


An Ontological AI-and-Law Framework for the Autonomous Levels of AI Legal Reasoning

A framework is proposed that seeks to identify and establish a set of ro...

Computer Modeling of Personal Autonomy and Legal Equilibrium

Empirical studies of personal autonomy as state and status of individual...

Robustness and Overcoming Brittleness of AI-Enabled Legal Micro-Directives: The Role of Autonomous Levels of AI Legal Reasoning

Recent research by legal scholars suggests that the law might inevitably...

The Next Era of American Law Amid the Advent of Autonomous AI Legal Reasoning

Legal scholars have postulated that there have been three eras of Americ...

Lawmaps: Enabling Legal AI development through Visualisation of the Implicit Structure of Legislation and Lawyerly Process

Modelling that exploits visual elements and information visualisation ar...

Artificial Intelligence and Legal Liability

A recent issue of a popular computing journal asked which laws would app...

Sublanguage: A Serious Issue Affects Pretrained Models in Legal Domain

Legal English is a sublanguage that is important for everyone but not fo...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.