Argument Undermining: Counter-Argument Generation by Attacking Weak Premises

by   Milad Alshomary, et al.

Text generation has received a lot of attention in computational argumentation research as of recent. A particularly challenging task is the generation of counter-arguments. So far, approaches primarily focus on rebutting a given conclusion, yet other ways to counter an argument exist. In this work, we go beyond previous research by exploring argument undermining, that is, countering an argument by attacking one of its premises. We hypothesize that identifying the argument's weak premises is key to effective countering. Accordingly, we propose a pipeline approach that first assesses the premises' strength and then generates a counter-argument targeting the weak ones. On the one hand, both manual and automatic evaluation proves the importance of identifying weak premises in counter-argument generation. On the other hand, when considering correctness and content richness, human annotators favored our approach over state-of-the-art counter-argument generation.



There are no comments yet.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Argument Generation with Retrieval, Planning, and Realization

Automatic argument generation is an appealing but challenging task. In t...

Neural Argument Generation Augmented with Externally Retrieved Evidence

High quality arguments are essential elements for human reasoning and de...

Aspect-Based Argument Mining

Computational Argumentation in general and Argument Mining in particular...

Assessing the Sufficiency of Arguments through Conclusion Generation

The premises of an argument give evidence or other reasons to support a ...

Empirical bounds for functions with weak interactions

We provide sharp empirical estimates of expectation, variance and normal...

Towards Knowledge-Grounded Counter Narrative Generation for Hate Speech

Tackling online hatred using informed textual responses - called counter...

ENTRUST: Argument Reframing with Language Models and Entailment

"Framing" involves the positive or negative presentation of an argument ...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.