Applying the Estimand and Target Trial frameworks to external control analyses using observational data: a case study in the solid tumor setting

08/13/2022
by   Letizia Polito, et al.
0

In causal inference, the correct formulation of the scientific question of interest is a crucial step. Here we apply the estimand framework to a comparison of the outcomes of patient-level clinical trials and observational data to help structure the clinical question. In addition, we complement the estimand framework with the target trial framework to address specific issues in defining the estimand attributes using observational data and discuss synergies and differences of the two frameworks. Whereas the estimand framework proves useful to address the challenge that in clinical trials and routine clinical practice patients may switch to subsequent systemic therapies after the initially assigned systematic treatment, the target trial framework supports addressing challenges around baseline confounding and the index date. We apply the combined framework to compare long-term outcomes of a pooled set of three previously reported randomized phase 3 trials studying patients with metastatic non-small cell lung cancer receiving front-line chemotherapy (randomized clinical trial cohort) and similar patients treated with front-line chemotherapy as part of routine clinical care (observational comparative cohort). We illustrate the process to define the estimand attributes and select the estimator to estimate the estimand of interest while accounting for key baseline confounders, index date, and receipt of subsequent therapies. The proposed combined framework provides more clarity on the causal contrast of interest and the estimator to adopt and thus facilitates design and interpretation of the analyses.

READ FULL TEXT
research
10/01/2020

Estimands in Hematologic Oncology Trials

The estimand framework included in the addendum to the ICH E9 guideline ...
research
03/10/2022

Multi-Task Adversarial Learning for Treatment Effect Estimation in Basket Trials

Estimating treatment effects from observational data provides insights a...
research
05/02/2021

Synthesized Difference in Differences

Randomized clinical trials (RCTs) eliminate confounding but impose stric...
research
09/27/2022

Multistate Models as a Framework for Estimand Specification in Clinical Trials of Complex Processes

Intensity-based multistate models provide a useful framework for charact...
research
09/20/2023

Confounding by Scarcity: An Overlooked Source of Bias in Pragma@c Trials

Pragmatic trials evaluate the effectiveness of health interventions comp...
research
04/08/2022

Long-term effect estimation when combining clinical trial and observational follow-up datasets

Combining experimental and observational follow-up datasets has received...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset