Analyses of 'change scores' do not estimate causal effects in observational data

07/05/2019
by   Peter W. G. Tennant, et al.
0

Background: In longitudinal data, it is common to create 'change scores' by subtracting measurements taken at baseline from those taken at follow-up, and then to analyse the resulting 'change' as the outcome variable. In observational data, this approach can produce misleading causal effect estimates. The present article uses directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) and simple simulations to provide an accessible explanation of why change scores do not estimate causal effects in observational data. Methods: Data were simulated to match three general scenarios where the variable representing measurements of the outcome at baseline was a 1) competing exposure, 2) confounder, or 3) mediator for the total causal effect of the exposure on the variable representing measurements of the outcome at follow-up. Regression coefficients were compared between change-score analyses and DAG-informed analyses. Results: Change-score analyses do not provide meaningful causal effect estimates unless the variable representing measurements of the outcome at baseline is a competing exposure, as in a randomised experiment. Where such variables (i.e. baseline measurements of the outcome) are confounders or mediators, the conclusions drawn from analyses of change scores diverge (potentially substantially) from those of DAG-informed analyses. Conclusions: Future observational studies that seek causal effect estimates should avoid analysing change scores and adopt alternative analytical strategies.

READ FULL TEXT

page 18

page 19

page 21

research
02/03/2023

Lord's 'paradox' explained: the 50-year warning on the use of 'change scores' in observational data

BACKGROUND: In 1967, Frederick Lord posed a conundrum that has confused ...
research
06/13/2012

The Evaluation of Causal Effects in Studies with an Unobserved Exposure/Outcome Variable: Bounds and Identification

This paper deals with the problem of evaluating the causal effect using ...
research
03/28/2018

Estimating causal effects of time-dependent exposures on a binary endpoint in a high-dimensional setting

Recently, the intervention calculus when the DAG is absent (IDA) method ...
research
06/17/2020

Combining Experimental and Observational Data to Estimate Treatment Effects on Long Term Outcomes

There has been an increase in interest in experimental evaluations to es...
research
02/03/2021

Sensitivity Analysis for Unmeasured Confounding via Effect Extrapolation

Inferring the causal effect of a non-randomly assigned exposure on an ou...
research
04/18/2020

Causal Effects of Prenatal Drug Exposure on Birth Defects with Missing by Terathanasia

We investigate the causal effects of drug exposure on birth defects, mot...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset