An Imprecise Probability Approach for Abstract Argumentation based on Credal Sets

by   Mariela Morveli-Espinoza, et al.

Some abstract argumentation approaches consider that arguments have a degree of uncertainty, which impacts on the degree of uncertainty of the extensions obtained from a abstract argumentation framework (AAF) under a semantics. In these approaches, both the uncertainty of the arguments and of the extensions are modeled by means of precise probability values. However, in many real life situations the exact probabilities values are unknown and sometimes there is a need for aggregating the probability values of different sources. In this paper, we tackle the problem of calculating the degree of uncertainty of the extensions considering that the probability values of the arguments are imprecise. We use credal sets to model the uncertainty values of arguments and from these credal sets, we calculate the lower and upper bounds of the extensions. We study some properties of the suggested approach and illustrate it with an scenario of decision making.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


On Computing Stable Extensions of Abstract Argumentation Frameworks

An abstract argumentation framework (af for short) is a directed graph (...

Verifiability of Argumentation Semantics

Dung's abstract argumentation theory is a widely used formalism to model...

Equilibrium States in Numerical Argumentation Networks

Given an argumentation network with initial values to the arguments, we ...

On the preferred extensions of argumentation frameworks: bijections with naive extensions

This paper deals with the problem of finding the preferred extensions of...

Probabilistic Argumentation with Epistemic Extensions and Incomplete Information

Abstract argumentation offers an appealing way of representing and evalu...

Revisiting initial sets in abstract argumentation

We revisit the notion of initial sets by Xu and Cayrol, i.e., non-empty ...

The Estimation of Subjective Probabilities via Categorical Judgments of Uncertainty

Theoretically as well as experimentally it is investigated how people re...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset