An Exploratory Study of Argumentative Writing by Young Students: A Transformer-based Approach

06/17/2020
by   Debanjan Ghosh, et al.
0

We present a computational exploration of argument critique writing by young students. Middle school students were asked to criticize an argument presented in the prompt, focusing on identifying and explaining the reasoning flaws. This task resembles an established college-level argument critique task. Lexical and discourse features that utilize detailed domain knowledge to identify critiques exist for the college task but do not perform well on the young students data. Instead, transformer-based architecture (e.g., BERT) fine-tuned on a large corpus of critique essays from the college task performs much better (over 20 improvement in F1 score). Analysis of the performance of various configurations of the system suggests that while children's writing does not exhibit the standard discourse structure of an argumentative essay, it does share basic local sequential structures with the more mature writers.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
11/26/2020

Transformer-Based Models for Automatic Identification of Argument Relations: A Cross-Domain Evaluation

Argument Mining is defined as the task of automatically identifying and ...
research
06/07/2023

Cross-Genre Argument Mining: Can Language Models Automatically Fill in Missing Discourse Markers?

Available corpora for Argument Mining differ along several axes, and one...
research
06/01/2023

Predicting the Quality of Revisions in Argumentative Writing

The ability to revise in response to feedback is critical to students' w...
research
03/08/2021

"Sharks are not the threat humans are": Argument Component Segmentation in School Student Essays

Argument mining is often addressed by a pipeline method where segmentati...
research
05/10/2010

Recognizability of Individual Creative Style Within and Across Domains: Preliminary Studies

It is hypothesized that creativity arises from the self-mending capacity...
research
10/24/2022

Toward an Intelligent Tutoring System for Argument Mining in Legal Texts

We propose an adaptive environment (CABINET) to support caselaw analysis...
research
09/12/2023

Use neural networks to recognize students' handwritten letters and incorrect symbols

Correcting students' multiple-choice answers is a repetitive and mechani...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset