Almost Envy-Free Allocations with Connected Bundles

by   Vittorio Bilò, et al.

We study the existence of allocations of indivisible goods that are envy-free up to one good (EF1), under the additional constraint that each bundle needs to be connected in an underlying item graph G. When the items are arranged in a path, we show that EF1 allocations are guaranteed to exist for arbitrary monotonic utility functions over bundles, provided that either there are at most four agents, or there are any number of agents but they all have identical utility functions. Our existence proofs are based on classical arguments from the divisible cake-cutting setting, and involve discrete analogues of cut-and-choose, of Stromquist's moving-knife protocol, and of the Su-Simmons argument based on Sperner's lemma. Sperner's lemma can also be used to show that on a path, an EF2 allocation exists for any number of agents. Except for the results using Sperner's lemma, all of our procedures can be implemented by efficient algorithms. Our positive results for paths imply the existence of connected EF1 or EF2 allocations whenever G is traceable, i.e., contains a Hamiltonian path. For the case of two agents, we completely characterize the class of graphs G that guarantee the existence of EF1 allocations as the class of graphs whose biconnected components are arranged in a path. This class is strictly larger than the class of traceable graphs; one can be check in linear time whether a graph belongs to this class, and if so return an EF1 allocation.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Extension of Additive Valuations to General Valuations on the Existence of EFX

Envy-freeness is one of the most widely studied notions in fair division...

Fair division of graphs and of tangled cakes

A tangle is a connected topological space constructed by gluing several ...

Locally EFX Allocations Over a Graph

The fairness notion of envy-free up to any good (EFX) has recently gaine...

One Dollar Each Eliminates Envy

We study the fair division of a collection of m indivisible goods amongs...

Simple Necessary Conditions for the Existence of a Hamiltonian Path with Applications to Cactus Graphs

We describe some necessary conditions for the existence of a Hamiltonian...

How to cut a discrete cake fairly

Cake-cutting is a fundamental model of dividing a heterogeneous resource...

A Discrete and Bounded Envy-Free Cake Cutting Protocol for Any Number of Agents

We consider the well-studied cake cutting problem in which the goal is t...