Against Scale: Provocations and Resistances to Scale Thinking

by   Alex Hanna, et al.

At the heart of what drives the bulk of innovation and activity in Silicon Valley and elsewhere is scalability. This unwavering commitment to scalability – to identify strategies for efficient growth – is at the heart of what we refer to as "scale thinking." Whether people are aware of it or not, scale thinking is all-encompassing. It is not just an attribute of one's product, service, or company, but frames how one thinks about the world (what constitutes it and how it can be observed and measured), its problems (what is a problem worth solving versus not), and the possible technological fixes for those problems. This paper examines different facets of scale thinking and its implication on how we view technology and collaborative work. We argue that technological solutions grounded in scale thinking are unlikely to be as liberatory or effective at deep, systemic change as their purveyors imagine. Rather, solutions which resist scale thinking are necessary to undo the social structures which lie at the heart of social inequality. We draw on recent work on mutual aid networks and propose questions to ask of collaborative work systems as a means to evaluate technological solutions and guide designers in identifying sites of resistance to scale thinking.



There are no comments yet.


page 2


Decomposable Problems, Niching, and Scalability of Multiobjective Estimation of Distribution Algorithms

The paper analyzes the scalability of multiobjective estimation of distr...

Cross-contextual use of integrated information systems

Large-scale organizations are increasingly promoting more collaborative ...

Patent Portfolio Analysis of Cities: Statistics and Maps of Technological Inventiveness

Cities are engines of the knowledge-based economy, because they are the ...

Boom, Bust, and Bitcoin: Bitcoin-Bubbles As Innovation Accelerators

Bitcoin represents one of the most interesting technological breakthroug...

Arctic connectivity: A frugal approach to infrastructural development

As the Arctic is heating up, so are efforts to strengthen connectivity w...

On temporal homogenization in the numerical simulation of atherosclerotic plaque growth

A temporal homogenization approach for the numerical simulation of ather...

The more you ask, the less you get: the negative impact of collaborative overload on performance

This paper is about the possible negative impact of excessive collaborat...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.