A pragmatic account of the weak evidence effect

12/07/2021
by   Samuel A. Barnett, et al.
0

Language is not only used to inform. We often seek to persuade by arguing in favor of a particular view. Persuasion raises a number of challenges for classical accounts of belief updating, as information cannot be taken at face value. How should listeners account for a speaker's "hidden agenda" when incorporating new information? Here, we extend recent probabilistic models of recursive social reasoning to allow for persuasive goals and show that our model provides a new pragmatic explanation for why weakly favorable arguments may backfire, a phenomenon known as the weak evidence effect. Critically, our model predicts a relationship between belief updating and speaker expectations: weak evidence should only backfire when speakers are expected to act under persuasive goals, implying the absence of stronger evidence. We introduce a simple experimental paradigm called the Stick Contest to measure the extent to which the weak evidence effect depends on speaker expectations, and show that a pragmatic listener model accounts for the empirical data better than alternative models. Our findings suggest potential avenues for rational models of social reasoning to further illuminate decision-making phenomena.

READ FULL TEXT

page 8

page 13

research
02/13/2013

Approximations for Decision Making in the Dempster-Shafer Theory of Evidence

The computational complexity of reasoning within the Dempster-Shafer the...
research
07/24/2018

Speakers account for asymmetries in visual perspective so listeners don't have to

Debates over adults' theory of mind use have been fueled by surprising f...
research
05/25/2021

Extending rational models of communication from beliefs to actions

Speakers communicate to influence their partner's beliefs and shape thei...
research
07/15/2018

A Mathematical Account of Soft Evidence, and of Jeffrey's `destructive' versus Pearl's `constructive' updating

Evidence in probabilistic reasoning may be `hard' or `soft', that is, it...
research
12/17/2021

Relativistic Conceptions of Trustworthiness: Implications for the Trustworthy Status of National Identification Systems

Trustworthiness is typically regarded as a desirable feature of national...
research
06/11/2013

The Effect of Biased Communications On Both Trusting and Suspicious Voters

In recent studies of political decision-making, apparently anomalous beh...
research
03/27/2013

Explanation of Probabilistic Inference for Decision Support Systems

An automated explanation facility for Bayesian conditioning aimed at imp...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset