A Contribution to the Defense of Liquid Democracy

06/28/2022
by   Gregory Butterworth, et al.
0

Liquid democracy is a hybrid direct-representative decision making process that provides each voter with the option of either voting directly or to delegate their vote to another voter, i.e., to a representative of their choice. One of the proposed advantages of liquid democracy is that, in general, it is assumed that voters will delegate their vote to others that are better informed, which leads to more informed and better decisions. Considering an audience from various knowledge domains, we provide an accessible high-level analysis of a prominent critique of liquid democracy by Caragiannis and Micha. Caragiannis and Micha's critique contains three central topics: 1. Analysis using their α-delegation model, which does not assume delegation to the more informed; 2. Novel delegation network structures where it is advantageous to delegate to the less informed rather than the more informed; and 3. Due to NP hardness, the implied impracticability of a social network obtaining an optimal delegation structure. We show that in the real world, Caragiannis and Micha's critique of liquid democracy has little or no relevance. Respectively, our critique is based on: 1. The identification of incorrect α-delegation model assumptions; 2. A lack of novel delegation structures and their effect in a real-world implementation of liquid democracy, which would be guaranteed with constraints that sensibly distribute voting power; and 3. The irrelevance of an optimal delegation structure if the correct result is guaranteed regardless. We conclude that Caragiannis and Micha's critique has no significant negative relevance to the proposition of liquid democracy.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
07/17/2018

A Mathematical Model for Optimal Decisions in a Representative Democracy

Direct democracy is a special case of an ensemble of classifiers, where ...
research
05/18/2023

The Wisdom of Strategic Voting

We study the voting game where agents' preferences are endogenously deci...
research
08/04/2022

Simulation and application of COVID-19 compartment model using physic-informed neural network

In this work, SVEIDR model and its variants (Aged, Vaccination-structure...
research
10/25/2020

The Smoothed Complexity of Computing Kemeny and Slater Rankings

The computational complexity of winner determination under common voting...
research
10/30/2018

Informed Democracy: Voting-based Novelty Detection for Action Recognition

Novelty detection is crucial for real-life applications. While it is com...
research
08/11/2023

Software Doping Analysis for Human Oversight

This article introduces a framework that is meant to assist in mitigatin...
research
05/23/2019

Why Didn't You Listen to Me? Comparing User Control of Human-in-the-Loop Topic Models

To address the lack of comparative evaluation of Human-in-the-Loop Topic...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset