A Comparative Study of Nonlinear MPC and Differential-Flatness-Based Control for Quadrotor Agile Flight

by   Sihao Sun, et al.

Accurate trajectory tracking control for quadrotors is essential for safe navigation in cluttered environments. However, this is challenging in agile flights due to nonlinear dynamics, complex aerodynamic effects, and actuation constraints. In this article, we empirically compare two state-of-the-art control frameworks: the nonlinear-model-predictive controller (NMPC) and the differential-flatness-based controller (DFBC), by tracking a wide variety of agile trajectories at speeds up to 72 km/h. The comparisons are performed in both simulation and real-world environments to systematically evaluate both methods from the aspect of tracking accuracy, robustness, and computational efficiency. We show the superiority of NMPC in tracking dynamically infeasible trajectories, at the cost of higher computation time and risk of numerical convergence issues. For both methods, we also quantitatively study the effect of adding an inner-loop controller using the incremental nonlinear dynamic inversion (INDI) method, and the effect of adding an aerodynamic drag model. Our real-world experiments, performed in one of the world's largest motion capture systems, demonstrate more than 78 NMPC and DFBC, indicating the necessity of using an inner-loop controller and aerodynamic drag model for agile trajectory tracking.


Global Incremental Flight Control for Agile Maneuvering of a Tailsitter Flying Wing

This paper proposes a novel control law for accurate tracking of agile t...

Quadrotor Trajectory Tracking with Learned Dynamics: Joint Koopman-based Learning of System Models and Function Dictionaries

Nonlinear dynamical effects are crucial to the operation of many agile r...

Performance, Precision, and Payloads: Adaptive Nonlinear MPC for Quadrotors

Agile quadrotor flight in challenging environments has the potential to ...

Modelling, identification and geometric control of autonomous quadcopters for agile maneuvering

This paper presents a multi-step procedure to construct the dynamic moti...

Nonlinear MPC for Quadrotors in Close-Proximity Flight with Neural Network Downwash Prediction

Swarm aerial robots are required to maintain close proximity to successf...

NeuroBEM: Hybrid Aerodynamic Quadrotor Model

Quadrotors are extremely agile, so much in fact, that classic first-prin...

Robust, High-Rate Trajectory Tracking on Insect-Scale Soft-Actuated Aerial Robots with Deep-Learned Tube MPC

Accurate and agile trajectory tracking in sub-gram Micro Aerial Vehicles...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset