A calibrated sensitivity analysis for matched observational studies with application to the effect of second-hand smoke exposure on blood lead levels in U.S. children

12/01/2018
by   Bo Zhang, et al.
0

Matched observational studies are commonly used to study treatment effects in non-randomized data. After matching for observed confounders, there could remain bias from unobserved confounders. A standard way to address this problem is to do a sensitivity analysis. A sensitivity analysis asks how sensitive the result is to a hypothesized unmeasured confounder U. One method, known as simultaneous sensitivity analysis, has two sensitivity parameters: one relating U to treatment assignment and the other to response. This method assumes that in each matched set, U is distributed to make the bias worst. This approach has two concerning features. First, this worst case distribution of U in each matched set does not correspond to a realistic distribution of U in the population. Second, sensitivity parameters are in absolute scales which are hard to compare to observed covariates. We address these concerns by introducing a method that endows U with a probability distribution in the population and calibrates the unmeasured confounder to the observed covariates. We compare our method to simultaneous sensitivity analysis in simulations and in a study of the effect of second-hand smoke exposure on blood lead levels in U.S. children.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
04/02/2020

On Interactions Between Observed and Unobserved Covariates in Matched Observational Studies

In observational studies, it is typically unrealistic to assume that tre...
research
01/07/2019

Patterns of Effects and Sensitivity Analysis for Differences-in-Differences

Applied analysts often use the differences-in-differences (DID) method t...
research
05/03/2021

Combining Broad and Narrow Case Definitions in Matched Case-Control Studies

In a matched case-control study, cases are compared to noncases, who are...
research
12/19/2018

Multivariate one-sided testing in matched observational studies as an adversarial game

We present a multivariate one-sided sensitivity analysis for matched obs...
research
02/13/2023

SelectionBias: An R Package for Bounding Selection Bias

Selection bias can occur when subjects are included or excluded in the a...
research
09/02/2022

Using Case Description Information to Reduce Sensitivity to Bias for the Attributable Fraction Among the Exposed

The attributable fraction among the exposed (AF_e), also known as the at...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset