Multilevel Models Allow Modular Specification of What and Where to Regularize, Especially in Small Area Estimation

05/21/2018
by   Michael Tzen, et al.
0

Through the lense of multilevel model (MLM) specification and regularization, this is a connect-the-dots introductory summary of Small Area Estimation, e.g. small group prediction informed by a complex sampling design. While a comprehensive book is (Rao and Molina 2015), the goal of this paper is to get interested researchers up to speed with some current developments. We first provide historical context of two kinds of regularization: 1) the regularization 'within' the components of a predictor and 2) the regularization 'between' outcome and predictor. We focus on the MLM framework as it allows the analyst to flexibly control the targets of the regularization. The flexible control is useful when analysts want to overcome shortcomings in design-based estimates. We'll describe the precision deficiencies (high variance) typical of design-based estimates of small groups. We then highlight an interesting MLM example from (Chaudhuri and Ghosh 2011) that integrates both kinds of regularization (between and within). The key idea is to use the design-based variance to control the amount of 'between' regularization and prior information to regularize the components 'within' a predictor. The goal is to let the design-based estimate have authority (when precise) but defer to a model-based prediction when imprecise. We conclude by discussing optional criteria to incorporate into a MLM prediction and possible entrypoints for extensions.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
09/04/2022

Conjugate Modeling Approaches for Small Area Estimation with Heteroscedastic Structure

Small area estimation has become an important tool in official statistic...
research
07/10/2021

Cluster Regularization via a Hierarchical Feature Regression

Prediction tasks with high-dimensional nonorthogonal predictor sets pose...
research
01/31/2023

Small area estimation under unit-level generalized additive models for location, scale and shape

Small Area Estimation (SAE) models commonly assume Normal distribution o...
research
06/28/2020

Improved Small Area Estimation via Compromise Regression Weights

Shrinkage estimates of small domain parameters typically utilize a combi...
research
12/01/2018

Quantifying the uncertainty of variance partitioning estimates of ecological datasets

An important objective of experimental biology is the quantification of ...
research
02/09/2023

Reliable event rates for disease mapping

When analyzing spatially referenced event data, the criteria for declari...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset